Octavia Gone by Jack McDevitt

Review by Cyndi J. (cyndij)

OCTAVIA GONE by Jack McDevitt is the 8th and so far latest in his Alex Benedict series.  It’s a pretty good SF series but I recommend a new reader starting with an earlier book, as this one relies on the reader knowing about events from past books.

 The time frame is somewhere around 9,000 years in our future. Alex is an antiquities dealer, tracking down artifacts from past civilizations along with his assistant Chase Kolpath. The story as always is told from Chase’s POV. Over the course of the series they’ve had some hair-raising adventures.  These books also always have a puzzle or mystery as the plot driver.

In this book, Alex’s uncle Gabe has just been rescued from a passenger spacecraft that went missing for over 10 years. For Gabe, however, it seems like only a few weeks have passed. Several previous books have mentioned Gabe and the last one, COMING HOME, dealt with how the rescue was accomplished.

While everyone is getting to know each other again, Gabe (who is an archaeologist) remembers an odd trophy someone gave him, but during the past years the previous owner asked for it back and now it’s lost. Gabe was and is convinced that it was an alien artifact and he decides he needs to track it down.

Mystery #2 is the fate of the research station Octavia, which was looking into wormholes and mysteriously vanished a short time before Gabe himself went missing.  Some of the missing crew family members want Alex to see if he can find anything to figure it out, although after exhaustive government inquiries there may not be anything new to discover.

I have to say this isn’t one of the most exciting of the series. McDevitt never adds much emotional depth to his characters, which is too bad here, because potential clashes between Alex and Gabe could have been great. Chase as well has a failed relationship which she implies has a lasting impact on her, but again we’re not shown that.   The main thrust of this story is AI (artificial intelligence). 9000 years later this seems to be the main way that human society has changed.  Are AIs sapient life? Do they deserve to be treated as people? The question is still debated, but we know which side Chase and Gabe come down on.  Alex…well I didn’t think his position was quite so clear.

The two mysteries are interlocked in a tragic way, which the three will discover. Nobody ends up particularly happy with the outcome, but they do have the satisfaction of knowing what truth there is.

I’m going to give this an rating of just above average, mainly based on the slow pacing. Gabe’s homecoming should have sparked major household turmoil, but we only see a couple spats.  I liked the AI portions and I really would have liked more discussion of the ethical considerations around them. Some of the physical considerations were thought-provoking although McDevitt didn’t follow that much. And I have to say I always like watching them track down the next bit of information, it’s just that this time it seemed so, so, slow. In the end, I feel McDevitt should have stuck with more of the usual action scenarios, because there isn’t enough serious internal introspection or emotional content to make up for the lack.

The Corpse in the Snowman by Nicholas Blake

Review by Matt B. (BuffaloSavage)

This novel is set in the dramatic winter of 1940-1941, the beginning of WWII. The story begins when Nigel Strangeways, Blake’s series hero, is invited by a relative of his wife Georgia to investigate a case at the country mansion of the Restorick family, the quality of the place. The strange behavior of the family cat has necessitated the services of a detective. It seems the cat, during a séance, behaved in a way weird and unsettling even for a cat, attacking with ferocity something that was not there.

Strangeways is introduced into the Restorick mansion as a parapsychologist, but soon he is forced to resume his true identity as a private detective, after the beautiful, vain, shameless and deeply troubled Elizabeth Restorick, the younger sister of the host Hereward Restorick, is found hanged in her room.

Strangeways wonders whether her apparent suicide is in fact premeditated murder. Teaming up with his usual sidekick Inspector Blount, he explores the possibilities with the suspects being a bland psychiatrist from London who has been treating Elizabeth, a novelist with a proletarian background and a jealous flighty friend.

Nigel Strangeways’ wife Georgia is an explorer, an unusual avocation for a woman in those days. They discuss the case in terms that Nick and Nora Charles would use if Nick and Nora Charles had had classical educations at Oxford. Another interesting character is Clarissa Cavendish, former don whose specialty was 18th century England, who refers to the Georgian period as “my day.” Last but not least, we have among the characters two nice and spontaneous children. The reader can tell that Day Lewis, both a parent and school master, knew children and their ways.

Nicholas Blake is the pseudonym with which the illustrious English poet Cecil Day Lewis (among other things, the father of the actor Daniel, who played Lincoln and Chingachgook) wrote a score of detective novels for the steady source of income. His mystery novels are much appreciated by discerning readers who like a little heft with their whodunits. That is, the readers of Michael Innes, John LeCarre, Dorothy B. Hughes, or Patricia Highsmith.

The Asking Price by Henry Cecil

Review by Matt B. (BuffaloSavage)

In Just within the Law, Cecil describes his writing with, “The basis of my stories is the occurrence of an extremely improbable event, followed by completely logical action by all the characters in the story.”

In this comic crime novel, the extremely improbable event comes out of such a situation. In a London neighborhood in the mid-Sixties, Ronald Holbrook lives on a small competence that he built from lucrative dealings on the black market right after WWII. The house bought on the ill-gotten proceeds has been his home for twenty years. At fifty-seven, he finds himself unmarried and with zero intention to marry. However, seventeen-year-old Jane Doughty, the daughter of his next-door neighbors, has been infatuated with him literally her entire life. Her single goal – her steely obsession – is to be married to her Ronnieboy. This situation is first comic, then gradually becomes disturbing and sinister, and we get the extremely improbable event which precipitates another situation.

That’s all the story you’re getting out of me lest I spoil the surprising twists and turns that Cecil puts his characters through. Not only is Cecil gifted as to plotting and characterization (even the walk-ons live and breathe), but he builds suspense as skillfully as, say, Ruth Rendell. The dialogue is sharp and witty and English. Jane asks her Ronnieboy, who’s been resolutely putting off lovemaking, “Do virtuous women have fun? I don’t want to be like the Albert Memorial, all stuck up and nowhere to go.”

For many readers, English comic legal fiction means John Mortimer and his excellent Rumpole stories. Cecil has more generosity and charity and big-heartedness than Mortimer does. I can’t recommend Henry Cecil highly enough for his lucid prose, original tale-spinning, brilliant characterization, deft plotting and spellbinding surprises.

The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper

by Hallie Rubenhold

Review by jjares

This book tells the story of the five women killed by Jack the Ripper. This book is well-researched and tightly written. So that you know, this is not a book about Jack the Ripper. Interestingly, the author wants to remove these women (as much as possible) from the label of prostitution. So instead, the author concentrates on these women’s dreary, dismal lives, trying to eke out a simple existence. The young women’s names were Annie, Catherine, Elizabeth, Mary-Jane, and Polly (Mary Ann). This book turns these women into people instead of simply nameless victims.

This book shows Victorian British women’s difficulty caring for themselves without a husband’s support. The police generally labeled any unwed woman, on her own, as a prostitute. Polly (Mary Ann Nichols), the first victim, lost her husband to another woman (a neighbor). After her husband removed his support, Polly became a wandering person, just looking for pennies to find a night’s lodging.

While the newspapers were still telling about Polly’s murder, Annie Chapman became the next victim. Years earlier, Annie succumbed to liquor and lost her husband. Annie’s husband’s boss would not have a drunkard near his fashionable estate, so Annie’s husband reluctantly turned Annie out. When Annie’s husband’s weekly support did not arrive, she walked miles to find that her husband was dying. Annie fell apart with grief. At the same time, she was suffering from tuberculosis. However, she generally sold her crochet and needlework to earn a bed for the night.

Elizabeth Stride’s story is even more pitiful. Becoming a housemaid at seventeen, someone in the household seduced Elizabeth. By twenty-one (years old), Elizabeth had lost a baby and was treated for venereal disease (an excruciating, dangerous, and humiliating exercise involving the police). Eventually, Elizabeth married, but the marriage fell apart, possibly because Elizabeth could not have children (or at least carry them to term, probably because of latent venereal disease). Eventually, she fell into prostitution. However, she also demonstrated the terminal effects of the neuro-venereal disease (epileptic seizures, disorientation, etc.). Another victim was found on the same night that Elizabeth left this earth.

If possible, Catherine Eddowes’s story is even more pathetic. After her parents died of illnesses, the many Eddowes children quickly married or were sent to workhouses. Catherine received a workhouse education until she was sent to an uncle to find work. Catherine soon left their home and followed a traveling hawker (salesman of chapter books). They had multiple children. He never married Catherine but beat her regularly. Eventually, the family broke apart, and Catherine struck out independently. Finally, after years of ‘living rough,’ Catherine was found the same night as Elizabeth in Whitechapel.

About six weeks after this pair of deaths, the youngest victim would die –  Mary Jane Kelly. This young woman changed her story so much that people did not know if she was Welsh or Irish. No information Mary Jane gave was ever confirmed; the woman who died is unknown. However, she was an attractive woman used to the sex trade. Eventually, Mary Jane took up with a fellow drinker (Joe Barnett), and they lived together for eighteen months until he lost his job. After the couple argued, Barnett left. Hours later, Mary Jane was found in her bed.

Alcohol destroyed each of these women’s lives. This book is a sociological study of lower-class lives during the Victorian Era. This compelling book turns these statistics into tragic, complex beings before their gruesome deaths. The story does not include the details of the women’s deaths, which would have taken from the consequence of their lives. This is probably the most important book I’ve read this year. The author’s research shines on every page of this book; absolutely brilliant.

The Python Project by Victor Canning

Review by Matt B. (BuffaloSavage)

Only a rich person that goes for an elephant foot umbrella stand could love the python bracelet. Antique. Gold. Diamonds for eyes. Emeralds for scales. Creepy and corrupt, it has been stolen from its rich widow owner. The insurance company hires private investigator Rex Carver for its recovery.

Carver soon discovers that the thief – the ne’er do well brother of the rich vamp – has disappeared. Carver cajoles his partner, Hilda Wilkins, and her BF Olaf the Swede Sailor, to spend some of their vacation time around Mediterranean doing some investigations. Some early chapters vividly conjure places like Italy and Libya, an accessible place when this story was released in 1967, not so much after 1969.

After Carver locates the bad hat brother and his sleazy partner, however, the game changes completely. He enters the murky world of spies where all the heavy-hitters, no matter what side they are playing on, are cold-hearted bully boys and tough girls, jailers, torturers, and executioners. Canning held a view of espionage as dim as John le Carré’s, but Canning is not as solemn about it. The series hero Carver is not hard-boiled or full of angst, but impudent and irreverent in that winning way the English and Irish do so amusingly.

Rex Carver starred in four fast-paced adventure stories, all released between 1965 and 1968. This was Book 3. Carver occasionally works with Richard Marston, who was the hero of The Limbo Line (1963). Though one would expect Cannings’ book to be long out of print, in fact the Arcturus Press has released this story and The Whip Hand.

Canning was a Silver Dagger winner and named a Grand Master by the British Crime Writers Association. Read him and save him from becoming a neglected writer.

The Case of the Empty Tin by Erle Stanley Gardner

Review by Matt B. (BuffaloSavage)

I highly recommend this 1941 Perry Mason mystery. Usually Mason novels start in the lawyer’s office or a public place where a client can button-hole him for legal advice. But this one starts in the cozy Gentrie household. The family owns a small hardware store so they have to watch every cent. They take in a roomer for extra income. They can preserves to save money on food. They depend on both a spinster sister and hired woman to keep the housekeeping and cooking in order for the three active kids. It has its share of strains but what family doesn’t?

I suppose a certain kind of Mason fan will find the beginning slow, but as a hardcore fan who’s read a couple dozen of them, I’m relieved when it starts out in a different way. Also, in a way that brings to mind Alfred Hitchcock’s making the mundane suspenseful, Gardner puts the typical middle-class family in the center of the mystery.

Other elements make this mystery outstanding in the canon. Mason blithely breaks the law with lying to police officers, house-breaking, and flouting traffic laws with reckless driving and speeding. Della plays a much bigger role, helping Perry break into houses and elude the law. She also helps Perry think by asking germane questions and introducing points that women know but men have no clue.

Remember that this novel was probably serialized in the weekly magazine Saturday Evening Post before it was published between two covers. Therefore, there is a certain amount of recapitulation in the dialogue to get new readers up to speed. We post-modern readers can skim these sections.

Finally, there is no courtroom sequence in this one. This may disappoint some fans and elate others. My bottom line is that this should be the next Mason you read if you’re a fan.