The Luck of the Wheels by Megan Lindholm

Review by Cyndi J. (cyndij)

LUCK OF THE WHEELS is the fourth and final book in the Ki and Vandien Quartet (aka The Windsingers). Previous books which have been reviewed here on the PaperBackSwap Blog are here: HARPY’S FLIGHT, THE WINDSINGERS and THE LIMBRETH GATE.  In my opinion you could read this book as a standalone, since nothing in the plot hinges on anything that’s gone before. That’s a little disappointing to me, but more about that later.

Ki and Vandien could be referred to as gypsies (in this world they are called Romni), as they have no fixed abode except for the wagon drawn by Ki’s two horses. They live by hauling goods, and as this novel opens they’re broke, as usual, in a strange country, and need to find work.

They’re offered really good money to take a passenger to a town two weeks travel away – a teenager nicknamed Goat who has been apprenticed to his uncle. They ought to have taken notice of the large fee, and how eager the rest of the townspeople are to see the back of this kid. He is, even for a teenager, a nasty bit of work. And it gets worse, because on their first night a runaway girl shows up, with a tale of woe and begging for a ride to her fiance.

Along with the hostility between the two kids, Ki and Vandien need to be careful of the Duke’s men, who rampage through the countryside harassing travellers and looting what they will.  And when they try to drop off Willow, they’re soon embroiled in a plot to overthrow said Duke. It’s only going to get worse from here.  Great description of the fencing match at the festival, and we learn just a bit more about Vandien’s family and how he came to be on the road.

It was interesting how Lindholm shifted the plot from Goat’s disturbing personality and talents into the overthrow scheme. It was also interesting how she tried to shift Goat from pervert into victim. It wasn’t a bad rationale, but Lindholm did such a good job making the two teenagers both so despicable that I couldn’t get on board with her message of forgiveness.

I was disappointed that Lindholm did not follow up on the bombshell she dropped about Ki’s ancestry in the last book, not to mention how that particular world came to be. I don’t know if she intended more stories, but it did seem an odd thing to leave hanging.

This is not a series I would re-read, but you can see how Lindholm evolved as a writer over the set.  Good world-building, and the pacing improves each time. LUCK OF THE WHEELS is out of print as are the rest, but if you’re interested, it shouldn’t be too hard to find a copy.

The Kaiju Preservation Society by John Scalzi

Review by Cyndi J. (cyndij)

In the afterword to this stand-alone SF novel, Scalzi calls it a pop song – light and catchy. It’s a perfect description. Nothing about this takes itself seriously, and it’s such fun to read, with engaging heroes, evil villains, a bizarre alternate Earth, and Godzilla! Sorry, kaijus.

Jamie Gray gets fired from a great job just as the COVID-19 lockdown hits New York City.  But a new gig as a food delivery driver is going to end too, until Jamie meets a former acquaintance who just happens to need a strong back to work in an “animal rights organization”.   Jamie is desperate and signs up immediately, to be met with a long questionnaire that includes feelings about science fiction, not to mention multiple vaccinations.

As it turns out, the animals are not exactly here on Earth. They’re gigantic creatures in an alternate, jungl-y hot human-free alternate Earth, and they happen to look a lot like Godzilla. Turns out Godzilla was not just a movie invention after all.  The kaijus have evolved to use internal nuclear reactors in place of food and water, and the Kaiju Preservation Society is there to study and, yes, preserve them. But this big secret takes a lot of people to maintain and fund, and so is not exactly a secret for certain people back on Earth. As always there are some would really like to profit off the kaijus.

Scalzi’s characters all tend to sound alike, but no matter, the dialogue is funny, snarky, and with a lot of deadpan humor. The villain is suitably evil and gets his comeuppance as he should.  The alternate Earth is nicely described and horribly dangerous, but it’s all done with a grin.  I’m not familiar with the Godzilla-verse, so there might be a lot of funny references I didn’t pick up on. I didn’t find anything lacking, though.

It’s told from Jamie’s first-person POV, which gives the perfect framework for all the science bits to be explained to us as Jamie gets the information. There’s also something about Jamie which you may or may not catch as you read.  I did not until it was pointed out (which says something about me) but I’m not going to spoil it. If you are still curious after you read, leave a comment here.

Beasts of the Earth by James Wade

Review by Melissa B. (dragoneyes)

I knew I would probably like this book but I didn’t realize how much. It quickly drew me in and I ended up finishing it in one day. I haven’t done that with a book in a long time. The story is harsh, depressing, and very hard to read at times but it balances out with a story that is also humane, tender, and pulls at all of your heartstrings. The words literally flowed right off the page and I fell so immersed into this tale that I couldn’t pull myself away from it.

There are two main characters that the story revolves around. We have Michael, a young boy that lives in poverty with his mother and his sister that he adores. When his abusive father is let out of jail and comes home to stay, Michael’s life is turned upside down. Then there is Harlen, a maintenance worker at the school. He tends to keep to himself and to his routine. When a crime happens at the school, Harlen ends up being in the middle of it. The two stories eventually meld together to make one beautiful sob story.

This will, without a doubt, be a book that I will remember years down the road. It is a first book for me by this author but will definitely look into his other works.

City of Nightmares by Rebecca Schaeffer

Review by Melissa B. (dragoneyes)

I thought the concept of the story sounded intriguing. In a town where going to sleep can mean waking up as your worst nightmare… literally. Ness has seen it up close and personal. Her sister woke up as a giant spider and killed their dad right in front of her. This made Ness terrified of everything. The only place that she could feel safe was at the Friends of the Restless Soul. There you train to fight and vanquish nightmares. Ness makes sure she does just enough at the organization to keep herself there but also just a little less to keep her out of harm’s way. The city is full of nightmares though and there is no way to hide from them forever.

I really enjoyed this story. It kept me wanting to read more. I enjoyed the friendships that surrounded Ness and also enjoyed some of the creepy nightmares. The only downfall is that our main character could wear on you after a bit. She was quite repetitive in her fear and the image that her sister left in her head. Enough so that I found myself skimming those parts. Luckily, even though it is closer to the end, she does start to find her way and get a lot more confidence. Excited to see what the next book has in store.

The Daughter of Doctor Moreau by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Review by Cyndi J. (cyndij)

Most readers will recognize the name of Doctor Moreau from the classic H.G. Wells novel, The Island of Doctor Moreau, and settle back with anticipation of what’s to come.

Let’s call it historical SF.  Set in the Yucatan peninsula of colonial Mexico. Carlota Moreau is the teen-aged daughter of the title. She’s lived in the remote jungle hacienda all her life with only her father and a few others for company. Doctor Moreau is, maybe, a genius. He’s created something no one has ever done before, but has so far received no benefit. Carlota has never been in school, never been in society, never known anything except the hacienda, but she loves it there.  There are not too many others – Carlota and her father, Montgomery Laughton the alcoholic overseer, Ramona the housekeeper, and her father’s animal/human hybrid creations. Carlota knows them all and in fact, Cachito and Lupe are her best friends.

But life is about to change. Dr. Moreau is laden with debt, and so is Montgomery – both to the same man. Senor Lizaldes has funded Moreau for years, hoping for a manufactured creature he can use to work the fields.  The Europeans are desperate for workers in the cane fields, but the Mayan peoples – and others – are not eager to be treated as slaves. But Lizaldes is getting extremely impatient with the lack of progress. He wants his workers, or he’s going to withdraw his funding.

Eduardo Lizaldes is the son of their patron, and this handsome, arrogant young man comes uninvited to visit one day. He’s smitten with Carlota – or perhaps he just wants a conquest. Carlota is smitten with him – or perhaps she is obeying her father, who believes a marriage could solve his problems.  Montgomery is seething with anger at the presumption of this boy – or perhaps he’s jealous.  The hybrids just want to seek their own destiny.  But Doctor Moreau has more than one secret, and the situation is about to spiral out of control.

You won’t be surprised at anything that happens here, not if you’re paying attention. Told in alternating viewpoints of Carlota and Montgomery, it starts rather slowly but has a steady buildup of tension until everything breaks loose. The characters are well drawn and the setting is perfect for the story.  I did think the ending was a bit too easy, but the sweet and sad atmosphere created by Moreno-Garcia, plus characters Carlota and Montgomery,  make it worth reading.

The Limbreth Gate by Megan Lindholm

Review by Cyndi J. (cyndij)

This is the third book in the “Ki and Vandien Quartet”; the series is also known as “The Windsingers”. I reviewed the first and second books previously (HARPY’S FLIGHT and THE WINDSINGERS).  It is necessary to read them first for this one to make any sense.

In the last book, Ki made an enemy of one of the Windsingers, but she also gained the protection – though not friendship – of another.   Rebeke, the protector, has made it clear to the others that Ki is not to be interfered with, but Yoleth has already set a plan in motion.  She has made a bargain with the Limbreth, a bored god of another world, to lure Ki through a  gate that can be opened between the worlds.  The Windsingers have done this before with inconvenient people. Because the worlds must be “balanced”, one person must leave as another one enters, and the Limbreth is only too willing to sacrifice some of its own people in order to get new faces.  It’s a one-way trip.

Once in the Limbreth’s world, as they drink the water, a strange compulsion overtakes humans. They are compelled to travel on and find the Limbreth. They are repelled by the idea of eating meat or causing harm to any living thing.  They find peace and enlightenment but unfortunately they’re also starving to death – the locals do not provide any help. The Limbreth is already sucking up their life experiences and doesn’t really care if they die later.  Ki comes across another stranded traveler, Hollyika the Brurjan, a cat-like humanoid.

Lindholm is a very good prose stylist. Lots of imagery and atmosphere. But there’s so little action going on – there’s a lot of philosophical musings from Ki  after she’s been affected by the Limbreth about the meaning of her life and all.  And more of the same from the woman Jace who came out of that world, and more from Vandien, and more from…it goes on.  It’s good prose, but I grew impatient for something to happen. It’s very much in line with the other books, more introspection than action.

I found Vandien’s hesitation in freeing Ki very irritating. She’s obviously been mind-altered, she’s starving to death, and he’s moaning to himself “But she’s happy, should I do anything?” I identified a lot more with Hollyika, who takes a brute force approach to the problem.  In fact, I liked Hollyika more than either Ki or Vandien this time around, which was amusing.  Lindholm was trying to convey a message there, but it didn’t resonate at all  with me.

There is a huge discovery made about Ki which is just brushed on and then dropped. I assume it’s picked up in the next and last book, because it’s a major change and I’d love to know what she’s going to do with it.  There’s another huge discovery about how their world came to be, and it would be nice to see that explored too, but I’m doubtful Hobb can fit all that in.

As with the first two, it’s an interesting world, but unsurprising that the series is no longer in print. I have a copy of the last, and I’ll be picking it up before too long.